9 Best Oyster Mushroom Substitutes

Oyster mushroom are fungi that naturally grow near trees in the template and subtropical regions and are also grown commercially in many countries. These mushrooms are often large to medium in size, with short or non-existent stems.

Oyster mushroom have broad, thin, or fan-shaped caps with white, gray, or tan gills lining the underside. The grills are white and decremented, extending down onto the stem. These mushrooms have a delicate texture and mild, savory flavor.

Oyster mushroom are added to a variety of cuisines around the world but are most popular in Chinese, Japanese, and Korean cooking.

Oyster mushroom can be eaten raw, stir-fried, or added to salads, roasts, or grills; they can be swallowed whole, sliced, or cut up into pieces. It is a favorite for most vegans or vegetarians because they are meat substitutes.

Why Would You Need Oyster Mushroom Substitutes? 

You are not alone if you are wondering where to buy oyster mushroom. Oyster mushrooms, as delicious as they are, are seasonal and more expensive than other mushrooms.

They aren’t that readily available at your local grocery store, so you might need an Oyster mushroom substitutes on short notice unless you try growing them at home.

Best Oyster mushroom substitutes includes, Shiitake, Porcini, Baby Bella/ Cremini, Portobello, Chanterelle, Abalone, Matsutake, Morel, Maitake (Hen of The Wood), Enoki, Wood Ears Mushrooms.

Best Oyster Mushroom Substitutes

1. Shiitake Mushroom

If you are looking for oyster mushroom substitutes that perfectly replicate its taste and texture, then the option for shiitake mushrooms. Shiitake mushrooms are from Asia and probably the most popular; they are less expensive than oyster mushrooms and can be a perfect replacement.

Shiitake mushrooms come in a range of brown hues and have umbrella-shaped wide caps. It has a bold flavor and fleshy texture. This unique meaty texture also makes shiitake ideal for pan-frying or sautéing in a small amount of oil.

They also make an excellent vegetarian alternative to beef steak due to its succulent quality. You can use shiitake mushroom as an oyster mushroom alternative in many recipes if an oyster mushroom is way above your budget or to find.

2. Portobello Mushrooms

Portobello mushrooms are another popular vegetable consumed by vegetarians and meat eaters alike. They have an intense flavor than most vegetarian proteins. They have sporting and smooth caps with an even brown color and are renowned for their deep and earthy flavor.

Portobello mushroom is one of the biggest commercially produced mushrooms, with a thick texture and meaty taste. Unlike other mushrooms, Portobello mushrooms do not have a pungent smell. Their overall effect on a dish can be linked to oyster mushrooms.

Since they are seasonal, it is pretty easy to run into them at your local stores. Drizzle oil over the Portobello mushrooms to bring out their flavor, but remember to take off the fibrous part of the stem before cooking them.

3. Porcini Mushrooms

Porcini mushrooms are an excellent replacement for oyster mushrooms because of their meaty texture, which will take your dish to the next level.

Porcini has an earthy brown hue with a pungent smell which you can get used to, and nothing beats its great meaty taste and ability to hold its shape when cooked. If you can bear the pungent smell and like meaty mushrooms, then porcini mushrooms are also an excellent oyster mushroom substitute.

This fungus is widely used in Tuscany, Italy, and can be found in a variety of cuisines. These mushrooms are available both fresh and dried. Whatever you choose, both have the same qualities and are acceptable for any mushroom dish.

The dried and fresh porcini have been used for oyster mushroom substitutes for quite some time in Italy and France, with its meaty texture and a deep, earthy-sweet flavor that complements any dish it is added to.

Porcini mushrooms don’t shrink when cooked, even in stews or soups, which is their best quality. When cooked, some mushrooms lose some of their original size, whereas porcini mushrooms keep their bulk and taste even meatier.

4. Baby Bella/Cremini Mushroom

The baby Bella mushroom can be the ideal option for you because it has the meaty flavor of the king oyster mushroom and the delicate appearance of pearl mushrooms. The flavor of these fungus species is mild, and they are quite adaptable.

Adding some Cremini mushrooms to your dish adds perfect umami goodness. They have a slight almond taste, with a texture between oyster and button mushrooms.

Baby Bella mushroom also known as white button mushrooms or cremini mushrooms, they are coveted for their meaty flesh, which is why they are commercially produced on such a vast scale. 

5. Chanterelle Mushrooms

Chanterelle mushrooms might look like oyster mushrooms with their bright hue and wide cap, but the good news is they’re not quite as expensive as oysters. These mushrooms are characterized by their nutty, meaty, and almost peppery undertones, making them great oyster substitutes.

However, chanterelles are a common sight when foraging for wild mushrooms.

Because of their nutty flavor and meaty texture, chanterelle mushrooms are a staple in French cuisine. Chanterelles, like other wild mushrooms, can be pricey due to their scarcity and distinct features. Chanterelle mushrooms have a vase-shaped top and a yellow to bright orange tint.

You can also find dried chanterelles in grocery stores, which can also be cooked similarly. However, chanterelles contain toxic twins, so if you’re not an adept at finding wild mushrooms, be cautious. Do not collect or consume them if unsure.

6. Matsutake Mushrooms

Popularity of matsutake mushrooms is high throughout North America, Europe, and Asia. The most popular places to find them in Asian food are in Japanese and Korean dishes. Because of its distinctive, spicy aroma and flavor that is practically identical to an expensive oyster mushroom, Matsutake mushrooms are in high demand.

Matsutake, a versatile oyster mushroom substitute, can be consumed raw and fried but tastes most delicious when added to soups and sauces. They are in demand for their distinct, spicy aroma with a taste that is almost the same as an oyster mushroom.

The price of these mushrooms is high because they are suitable for vegetarians because of their unique flavor. They are best consumed with their natural and earthy flavor without additional seasoning. It is best enjoyed when fried in stew or soup.

7. Morel Mushroom

Another form of wild mushroom that can be discovered in the middle of the woods are morels. Although it doesn’t seem particularly attractive, you’ll be astonished by how meaty and nutty it tastes.

Morel mushrooms have a poisonous lookalike, so it’s best and safe to buy this type of mushroom from a grocery store. Despite how excellent they are, they are expensive because of the method they are collected and are only available during certain times of the year.

But if you ever have the opportunity to purchase them, take advantage of it and experience their rich, nutty flavor. When it comes to taste, Morel has a meaty, nutty flavor, just like an oyster mushroom.

8. Enoki Mushroom

Due to its numerous caps, enoki mushrooms can be mistaken for an oyster mushroom. They are all growing together in a large bouquet of white mushrooms, each with a long, slender stem and a tiny umbrella-shaped cap. You can add them to soups and stews.
Just be sure to add them at the last minute so you don’t overcook them – as this will ruin the taste. These mushrooms can be used in a variety of ways in the kitchen. They can be included in stews and soups. Just make sure to add them right before serving to avoid overcooking them and ruining the flavor.

Also, these mushrooms are not only delicious but pack a lot of nutritional value. They are also perfect in salads, sandwiches, or as a side dish. If they aren’t available fresh in your area, you can find them in cans or jars at your nearest grocery or specialty shop.

Enoki mushrooms make a satisfactory oyster mushroom substitutes for specific dishes, and their light and meaty texture may make it hard to tell the difference. Even if you made a few mistakes with the recipe, Enoki mushroom’s huge bulk and wholesome flavor would help cover up lost grounds and keep the dish mouthwatering.

9. Wood Ears Mushroom

Wood ears are another excellent alternative for oyster mushrooms. Wood ears is a masterpiece created not only by science but also by an artisan’s touch. Stores sell them dried.

It is not only a vegan oyster mushroom substitutes but also gluten-free. Wood ears have a similar crunchy texture as oysters without all that pesky cheese.

Frequently Asked Questions

What Is The Taste Of Oyster Mushroom?

Oyster mushrooms have a subtle seafood flavor with hints of anise and a faint, earthy taste. Cooked oyster mushrooms bring a soft, meaty texture to soups, stir-fries, and salad recipes.


However, you may sometimes crave oyster mushroom but can’t find it, and you want a replacement without compromising on its taste; with the above Oyster Mushroom substitutes, you are good to go.

You may not notice a difference in the substitutions you’re making if you study what type of mushroom you use.

Always know that some mushroom have a poisonous lookalike, so purchasing from a grocery store is advisable to avoid mistaking the poisonous one for the real one.

Related Posts

Leave a Comment