Can You Overboil Potatoes? ( All You Need Know)

Can you overboil potatoes is a question many people have been asking, especially when making mashed potatoes. Overboiled potatoes can be heartbroken, especially if you are making a dish that does not require overcooking the potatoes.

So, can you overboil potatoes? The answer to this question is based on your recipe, so different recipes have different methods. Your recipe might require overboiling potatoes, while another person own might not. Therefore, you can cook potatoes according to what your recipes demand. 

Can You Overboil Potatoes?

Yes, you can over-boil potatoes, as it won’t matter for some dishes since the texture is meant to be soft and mushy, like for mashed potatoes.

For instance, overboiled potatoes will not affect your recipe if you make mashed potatoes. Also, overboiling may burn the skin and turn it wrinkly when it comes to roasted potatoes.

So, you can use overboiled potatoes in recipes like mashed potatoes or purees, which require a blended, smooth texture. Also, Some recipes do not require overboiled potatoes, so overboiling can affect your dish.

However, if you find out that you overcooked your potatoes, don’t worry; you can always choose recipes that require them to avoid wasting or trashing them. Read on for more details on what to do with your overboiled potatoes.

What To Do When You Overboiled Your Potatoes

If you overboiled your potatoes, don’t feel bad and trash; we all know that food waste is harmful. So, you can convert your overboiled potatoes into different dishes without wasting them. Here is how you can convert your overoiled potatoes.

1. Dry It In An Oven Or Skillet

You can dry them in the oven or cook them in a skillet until the water dries completely. Ensure to add a little bit of oil to the surface to make it crispy and delicious. Avoid adding excess oil to prevent potatoes from frying, which is not what we want. 

2. Convert It To Mashed Potatoes

You can use it as mashed potatoes, drizzle some oil, butter, bacon grease, garlic cloves, or fried onion and enjoy. Doesn’t it sound delicious?

3. Convert It Into Potato Cream Soup

Preparing potato soup is another way to avoid wasting your overboiled potatoes. Mix the potatoes with coconut milk, and dress it with bacon, garlic bread, and curry powder to make it a perfect dish.

4. Use Them To Make Potato Croquettes

Using overboiled potatoes to make potato croquettes is another way to prevent food wastage. You will need flour for coating, some butter or bacon grease, cheese, eggs, and any seasoning you like.

You can skip the cheese if you like but remember it adds a unique flavor to your dish. What a yummy dish to start your day with.

How Long Can You Boil Potatoes?

Depending on your recipe, the different recipe calls for different cooking times, and according to the size of your potatoes, cooking potatoes takes about 10-20 minutes. Also, know that there are different types of potatoes. So everything differs.

For instance, floury potato used for mashing is usually cooked for 10 minutes after the water starts boiling. Also, If you’re using a waxy potato and would like to fry it, it can take up to 20 minutes to boil. Try poking them with a fork after about 15 minutes to see how far along they are to avoid overcooking them.

Here is how to boil potatoes for different dishes.

1. For Potato Salad

It would be best to have firm and waxy potatoes when preparing potato salad, which can cook for up to 20 minutes. Ensure you cut them the way you want in your salad because if you cook them whole, you will overcook the exterior.

Meanwhile, the best potatoes that keep their shape and are best for this dish are Yukon gold, red potatoes, Yellowfin, fingerlings, Anya, Charlotte, and Cornish Kings.

2. For Mashed Potato

In mashed potatoes, you need a floury, soft potato. These cook for about 10 minutes. Remember that overcooked potatoes can also be used for this recipe if you drain them well.

You can use a potato ricer and an electric mixer while mashing your potatoes. It is vital to use milk and butter to get that thick, creamy consistency we all love. You can use russet, King Edward, Marabel, or Vivaldi when preparing mashed potatoes.

3. For French Fries Or Baked Potatoes

It is essential to know that when preparing either French fries or baked potatoes, you don’t need to overcook them; instead, you undercook them a bit this is because they will still pass into a heating phase.

However, you can use any potato for this recipe if you do not overcook them.

How To Know An Overboiled Potatoes

You can tell if you overboiled your potatoes by checking their consistency with a spoon and when you notice excessive water in your boiled potatoes. Also, when you overcook potatoes, the skin will start to wrinkle.

However, you can check the consistency by pressing them using a spoon; if they release water, the potatoes are overcooked and must be recovered. But you are good to go if it is buttery, soft, and not mushy.

Why Do You Rinse Potatoes In Cold Water?

Soaking potatoes in water helps remove excess starch. Excess starch can inhibit the potatoes from cooking evenly and create a gummy or sticky texture outside your potatoes.

Cold water is used because hot water reacts with the starch activating it and making it harder to separate from the potatoes.

Should I Boil My Potatoes Whole Or Cut Them?

Regardless of what you’ve chosen to do with the peel, your potatoes will cook more quickly if you cut them into chunks before boiling. They don’t have to be super small, wildly if you are mashing them, but know that the smaller you cut the potatoes, the faster they will cook.

How Long Can You Boil Potatoes to Get Tender ?

The potatoes is cooked in gently boiling water until tender, about 15 minutes for small red potatoes, new or cubed large russet potatoes, and 20 to 25 minutes for quartered potatoes. Remember, the size of the potato pieces is a massive factor in how long it takes to boil potatoes.

Best Way to Boil Your Potatoes.

1. Don’t start with warm water; it ruins the taste of your potatoes.

2. If you are unsure about the time needed to boil your potatoes, try porking them with folk after 10 minutes of boiling to get the actual result.

3. Do not let your cooked potatoes sit in hot water, as they will continue cooking with the heat in the water.

4. Don’t boil your potatoes whole; it is better to cut them into even pieces to cook evenly (exterior and interior).


As we said before, overboiling potatoes depends on your recipe, as your recipe will determine how you will boil your potatoes. So, know what you want to make to avoid making mistakes.

However, Even if you overcook your potatoes, don’t worry; we got you. You can always change the recipe using any of the abovementioned recipes to fix your over-boiled boiled potatoes and be happy.

Related Posts.

Leave a Comment